The Savage Killing of Tax Protester Gordon Kahl

On June 3, 1983, a large police force consisting of approximately 20 officers and SWAT team members from the FBI and U.S. Marshals together with local and State officers and the sheriff of Lawrence County Arkansas, Gene Matthews, converged on and surrounded a rural cabin outside of Smithville, Arkansas.

According to information from a paid informant, and having the cabin under surveillance for several days, law enforcement officials believed that the occupants of the house, Norma and Leonard Ginter, were harboring federal fugitive Gordon Kahl.

The ensuing carnage that resulted from the raid can best be described as the pinnacle of gruesome. Gordon Kahl and Sheriff Gene Matthews both died of gunshot wounds. The official line is that the sheriff and Gordon Kahl shot and killed each other.

The fatal shootings occurred inside the cabin during the first few minutes of the raid. Afterward the Ginter home was assaulted with a thundering barrage of gunfire and tear gas and then destroyed by fire that was intentionally set by lawmen. The resulting inferno destroyed the corpse of Gordon Kahl which was still inside the cabin when it was set afire.

According to Leonard Ginter, he, his wife Norma and Gordon Kahl were sitting at the table eating supper. After finishing his meal Leonard left to go fishing. When he drove his pickup along the inclined driveway to the top of a hill he was intercepted by the FBI. They asked him who was inside the cabin. He said his wife Norma was there. When asked if Gordon Kahl was inside, Ginter responded: “Do you have a search warrant?” Whenever he was asked about Gordon Kahl, Ginter would respond, “Do you have a search warrant?”

[Leonard Ginter interview Tape #9 and Interview Tape #10.]

Ginter was escorted down the hill to the cabin. He called to his wife, “Norma come on out here, the FBI wants to talk to you.”

https://web.archive.org/web/20130120200218/https://www.taoslandandfilm.com/independent-films/Death-and-Taxes-interviews/transcript.php?Ed-Fitzpatrick (22/57)

After the Ginters were cleared from the cabin no one tried to establish communications with Kahl. Instead Sheriff Gene Matthews charged inside followed by U.S. Marshal Jim Hall and Arkansas State Trooper Ed Fitzpatrick.

Two shots were reportedly heard in rapid succession, almost simultaneously. Afterward Trooper Fitzpatrick ran out of the cabin to a kitchen window, shattered the glass with his shotgun and blasted several rounds into the kitchen area.

https://web.archive.org/web/20130120200218/https://www.taoslandandfilm.com/independent-films/Death-and-Taxes-interviews/transcript.php?Ed-Fitzpatrick (26/18)

Sheriff Matthews was armed with a .41 Magnum revolver; Gordon Kahl had his Ruger Mini-14, a semi-automatic .223 caliber rifle.

A letter, describing the fatal head wound of Gordon Kahl was written by Famay Malak, Chief Medical Examiner for the State of Arkansas, to prosecuting attorney Jim Stallcup, states that:

[T]he point of entry was above and slightly behind the right ear.

Regarding the shooting of Sheriff Matthews Malak wrote:

The angle of shooting is between 50 to 70 degrees to the horizontal. The direction of shooting was from below and upwards and from left to right. The bullet shattered the left upper arm and ricocheted to reenter the chest through the third space where it damaged the lung.

On page 5 of the autopsy report regarding Sheriff Gene Matthews, Dr. Malak described the direction of shooting:

From left back of the victim to ricochet up to reenter the chest at the armpit just above the armor vest.

The explanation that Gordon Kahl and Sheriff Gene Matthews shot and killed each other is totally inconsistent with the physical evidence. Gordon Kahl’s fatal bullet entry was “above and slightly behind the right ear,” consistent with being shot from behind while he was seated at the dining table. According to Dr. Malak the sheriff was also shot from behind.

  • Gordon Kahl and Sheriff Matthews were each shot from behind.

In his report Malak concludes the bullet that he removed from Gordon Kahl’s skull was fired by Sheriff Matthew’s revolver. Considering that the shooting occurred inside the cabin with a .41 Magnum revolver, it is difficult to understand why the skull wasn’t totally obliterated.

The official version is that Sheriff Matthews stumbled out of the cabin and collapsed. Law officers claimed he had no pulse and his pupils were dilated and non-reactive. He was rushed to Lawrence Memorial Hospital where he was pronounced dead two hours later after intensive emergency procedures failed to revive him.

During an interview with investigative reporter Gene Nail, Leonard Ginter provided alarming details.

Jim would jump up from behind this diversion (a wood pile) and just point in the direction of the house and pull the trigger, BBBRRPPTTT, you know he was using long clips of thirty rounds, flaying his rifle and when he would run out, he would drop down, throw that one, grab another one, stick it in there and shoot it until he ran out of ammo. … it was so preposterous, when there was nothing to be shooting at and yet that was the scene.

https://web.archive.org/web/20130120200223/http://taoslandandfilm.com/independent-films/Death-and-Taxes-interviews/transcript.php?Gene-Nail (52/07)

Now for the alarming part “Jim” was identified as FBI agent Jim Handley the very FBI agent who was head of the Arkansas FBI swat team!

Norma Ginter described the scene “like there was a big army out there” so much so that during the mass firing the “ground was vibrating.”

The bizarre behavior of law enforcement at the Ginter cabin challenges comprehension. During an interview FBI agent Dero Downing offered a viewpoint that remarkably illustrates the power of delusional thinking:

About the same time that teargas was ordered into the house [i.e. after Gordon Kahl was killed] mass firing took place as cover fire into the windows in an attempt to protect the individuals firing the teargas into the residence.

All this, according to Agent Downing, to protect the individuals who were firing tear gas into the cabin which was not the source of any hostile gunfire and in which the lone occupant was already dead.

According to Agent Downing, a decision was made to “accelerate the effects of the smoke in terms of burning the oxygen out of the air.” In other words, start a fire! This decision set the stage for the next act of the spasmodic clown show.

When Ravenden Police Officer, Tom Lee, arrived at the roadblock he heard a call over his radio “for some gas.” A civic-minded citizen provided him with a 3 gallon can of gasoline and a five gallon vessel half-filled with diesel fuel. Lee delivered the flammable liquids to the Ginter dwelling and helped carry the containers through the woods to the back of the cabin.

Eventually Lee climbed onto the roof and poured the diesel fuel into an air vent and into the cabin together with some smoke grenades.

During his on camera interview Lee further stated “there was smoke coming out of the windows that was broke in front of the house … some say they couldn’t tell if it was smoke or teargas because there’d been a world of teargas already put in.”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zYf9_RbWvV8&t=1423s

(41:36-42:50 Minutes)

FBI Agent Dero Downing explained that that FBI agents did not personally pour accelerants into the cabin:

The federal government denied physically using the accelerants. IN FACT IT WAS NOT A FEDERAL AGENT WHO PHYSICALLY POURED THE ACCELERANTS INTO THE AIR VENT. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zYf9_RbWvV8&t=1423s (42:51- 43:11 Minutes)

Why no it wasn’t the FBI who poured the accelerants down the air vent, they left that unsavory task to the village idiot, Tom Lee.

Almost three weeks after the raid, Ray Wade, the son of the landowner where the Ginter cabin was constructed, accompanied a reporter from the New York Times and escorted him inside the building. That’s when a grisly discovery was made.

While walking through the kitchen area Ray Wade accidentally kicked something. After picking the object off the floor he realized that he was holding the charred remains of a human foot!!

  • Even though the FBI alleged that a double homicide occurred inside the Ginter cabin no crime scene search was conducted.

Years later, in 1992, the body of Gordon Kahl was exhumed for a second autopsy performed by Dr. Thomas Noguchi. Noguchi’s findings are very disturbing and actually raise sill more questions.

In a preliminary report Noguchi outlined his findings:

The fire was intense and localized in the vicinity of the body. Knees and arms are more consumed by fire and the other areas are less involved. This pattern gives the impression that the intense fire was localized, rather than covering the overall area in which case the burn pattern would be even.

The damage to the ends of some bones, such as the femurs and tibia were caused by intense and prolonged fire.

Both knees were also consumed by the intense fire. Both femurs were consumed by fire at the distal ends.

Based on the information provided to me concerning the house contents and household materials, and the fact that the house was made of bare concrete and the concrete floor, walls and ceiling, would not have provided sufficient fuel material to create the intense and prolonged heat source described.

The Ginter house was constructed entirely of concrete and noncombustible Sheetrock: floor, walls and ceiling. Yet the fire inside the house raged for almost two hours. This was not merely the result of pathologic idiots pouring diesel fuel down the air vent. Even more strange, the heat was different at different places in the kitchen/living room area. Within a six foot area of where officers reported the body was found, there was a refrigerator, a stove, a storage cabinet, and a sink. The heat was so intense that it burned the paint entirely off the refrigerator, but the paint on the stove, only four feet away, was barely damaged.

Something terrible happened inside that cabin. It is not known how the fire damage was inflicted on the body of Gordon Kahl to produce the gruesome destruction of his arms and legs. Also unknown is how Gordon Kahl and Sheriff Gene Matthews were fatally wounded. What is certain is that Gordon Kahl and Gene Matthews did not shoot and kill each other.

– Mark Adams National Security Commentator